
Johnson’s projected ballot cushion stands at 943 signatures while challengers question how another candidate’s petitions and duplicate sheets entered his filing
Petition sheet bearing Chicago Treasurer Melissa Conyears-Ervin’s name, shared by P Rae on November 2 amid challenges to Mayor Brandon Johnson’s reelection filing
NBC Chicago reported that Conyears-Ervin petition sheets were included in Johnson’s submission
SubX.News®Politics Report Nov 22, 2026
Before the Bears game, take a look at the name on this petition.
Melissa Conyears-Ervin.
She is Chicago’s treasurer.
Brandon Johnson is Chicago’s mayor. Yet sheets bearing her name appeared in his reelection filing, according to NBC Chicago’s reporting.
Someone collected the documents.
Someone assembled the packet.
Someone numbered the pages.
Someone was responsible for checking it before submission.
Now election officials are going through the signatures while Johnson’s opponents, political analysts, and defenders argue over whether this was intentional padding, internal sabotage, or a campaign that failed to check its own work.
Wilson predicts trouble
Willie Wilson puts Johnson’s chances of missing the ballot at 90% or higher.
In his November 20 FOX 32 interview, Wilson said, “I know he in danger.”
When the interviewer estimated that Johnson could finish with approximately 14,000 valid signatures, Wilson agreed.
But he said additional objections involving certification and whole sheets could drive that number below the 12,500 required.
Wilson described watching his own campaign’s petition preparation and discarding questionable signatures. He said he did not know whether Johnson personally reviewed his filing.
“But he’s still responsible.”
Former state Sen. Rickey Hendon, working for Wilson, told NBC that their challenge was succeeding on registration and signature authenticity before reaching photocopies and duplicates.
“We haven’t even gotten to photocopies, duplicates, and we’re beating him hands down on registration or signatures.”
Odelson says intentional
Election attorney Burt Odelson describes deliberate padding.
In Ray Hanania’s November 17 account of their November 15 radio interview, Odelson said his team found at least 100 duplicate pairs, totaling 200 pages.
Sheets were copied before numbering, assigned different numbers, and inserted at different places in the packet.
“Photocopied, intentionally.”
Odelson also cited Conyears-Ervin petitions, forgeries, and missing notarizations.
“His petitions reflect his administration the last three years.”
Hanania doubts Johnson will ultimately be removed. He nevertheless questions what the filing says about the mayor’s ability to manage Chicago.
Calabrese supplies the count
Political consultant Frank Calabrese’s November 21 update reports:
- 5,048 challenged lines reviewed
- 3,702 invalidated
- 1,346 upheld
- 73.3% overall invalidation rate
At that rate, Calabrese projects roughly 13,400 valid signatures, about 900 above the minimum.
“It’s still too close to say if Johnson makes the ballot.”
He identifies further objections involving photocopied sheets and underage circulators.
Berg calculates the cushion
Austin Berg’s November 21 update puts the Chicago Policy Center projection at 13,443 valid signatures, 943 above the requirement.
Saturday’s invalidation rate was 73.1%. That slightly lowered the cumulative rate and raised the projected valid count by 21 signatures.
Only about 20% of challenged lines had been reviewed.
“Objections to photocopied sheets and circulator/notary problems could still knock out whole pages.”
Berg’s tracker uses preliminary Board reports published by Calabrese. Its projection can change with subsequent rulings and whole-sheet objections.
Sabotage or accountability?
P Rae offered an internal-sabotage explanation in her November 2 post accompanying the Conyears-Ervin photograph.
“Someone double crossed him and got paid 2x to do this to him while smiling in his face.”
She said the sheet was inserted after Johnson’s binder check. Her post does not identify who did it or provide evidence of payment.
Jessica R. Jackson and Zoe Marsh-Leigh’s signed November 2 objection demands Johnson’s disqualification.
Jackson argues that the conduct warrants removal even if enough individual signatures survive.
Danielle Carter-Williams, as NBC identifies her, makes an equal-treatment argument.
“If you don’t kick him off the ballot, then everybody has to be on that ballot.”
Lisa Nee attacks the process itself.
“This is just big money, cheap threats and same old bullying in Chicago, and voters are fed up with it.”
Johnson says he will survive
“I am confident that my signatures will hold up, and I will be on the ballot.”
Johnson’s campaign previously acknowledged that a few photocopies might have slipped into the filing. Johnson called the system “antiquated.”
NBC also quoted an unnamed source close to his team describing the challenge as an effort to discredit and embarrass a Black mayor for political gain.
That moves the argument from the paperwork to who is attacking the mayor.
What does this fight accomplish?
SubXNews published Cheat Sheets on November 13, examining matching voter entries under handwritten page numbers 53 and 79.
We put the documents before readers and asked who copied, numbered, checked, and submitted them.
I’ve run campaigns and faced signature challenges. I understand the work involved. I also understand that a political campaign can pursue objectives extending well beyond one candidate.
Look at the Chicago Policy Center’s tracker.
Beneath its calculations, it advocates changing ballot access through electronic petitions and discusses earlier proposals to bring that system to Illinois.
Here is my assessment of the larger fight.
Johnson can use the challenge to rally supporters around the argument that powerful interests want their mayor removed.
Organizers seeking changes to ballot access gain attention for rules they want rewritten.
People who distrust elections gain another controversy around which to organize.
Whether Johnson stays on the ballot determines one outcome.
Changing the rules can shape who gets onto future ballots and which organizations have the means to place them there.
Think about the 20 plus year long campaign for an elected school board.
People say CTU lost because they only have ten seats. Twenty years ago, there were no elected seats.
Individual candidates and elections came and went while organizers kept pursuing institutional change.
Watch the signatures.
Watch the people counting them.
And watch what each side asks the public to support next.
They already won. That’s the trick.
Disclosure
I was part of the group that took over the Chicago Teachers Union in 2010 with Karen Lewis. I helped put that movement’s leadership in power. My analysis is informed by firsthand experience inside the organization.
Source DRS™
Brandon Johnson Petition Sheets 53 and 79 (828a 12 Nov 26) @FrankCalabrese
https://x.com/FrankCalabrese/status/2120886331673042995
Johnson Petition Challenge Update (715p 21 Nov 26)
https://x.com/FrankCalabrese/status/2124310789049700685
Johnson Ballot Projection Update (21 Nov 26) @Austin__Berg
https://x.com/Austin__Berg/status/2124339947083878839
Chicago Mayor Johnson intentionally fattened his petitions with invalid signature sheets (17 Nov 26)
https://hanania.substack.com/…/chicago-mayor-johnson…
Johnson dismisses concerns as rivals scrutinize mayoral petition signatures (30 Oct 26)
https://abc7chicago.com/…/chicago-mayor…/20001004/
Johnson Petition Sabotage Claim (1006p 02 Nov 26) P Rae @ChicagoREDP
https://x.com/ChicagoREDP/status/2117468537337868452
Lightning Strike Radio Show Odelson Interview (15 Nov 26) WCPT AM 820
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WMRf1h_WGPU
Mayor Johnson’s petitions face increasing scrutiny (20 Nov 26)
https://www.nbcchicago.com/…/mayor-johnsons…/4019163/
Ms Jackson Calls for Johnson’s Disqualification (edited 800a 10 Nov 26)
https://x.com/moorrealnews4u/status/2120154753917215087
Painstaking review of challenge to Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson continues (641pm 18 Nov 26)
https://www.nbcchicago.com/…/painstaking…/4018628/
Will Brandon Johnson make the ballot (updated 21 Nov 26) Chicago Policy Center
https://willbrandonjohnsonmaketheballot.com/
Willie Wilson explains why his campaign is challenging Brandon Johnson’s signatures (526p 20 Nov 26) FOX 32 Chicago
https://www.fox32chicago.com/video/fmc-gw1xvyvkevjzeemu